Posted by admin on 14 June 2024 12:08:16 PM
Hello Artfighters,

Based on staff discussion and user feedback, we have made adjustments to the rules regarding suggestive themes. The edited rules can be found here.

   First and foremost, we’d like to clarify the reason that the changes to our suggestive themes filter had been made, specifically the section related to removing fetish art from the site, even if tagged under suggestive themes.

   Previously, we have had issues with a certain subset of users intentionally drawing art for (or requesting art from) unsuspecting and non-consenting users, some of whom were minors, that contained fetish art. This is called “fetish mining,” a practice wherein a user intentionally ropes another into participating in fetish works without the other user’s knowledge and consent. In order to combat this and reduce mod strain, we decided to remove fetish works from the “allowed” list under suggestive themes.

   Ultimately, after careful consideration of user feedback as well as several rounds of internal review, we decided that the removal of all fetish works was not going to help us combat this issue. Instead, it led to more uncertainty (as it is difficult to define what isn’t/is a fetish when it comes to suggestive work), as well as more moderator strain due to needing to delete all prior attacks/characters involving fetish. Instead, we have edited the filtering guide to once again allow fetishes, with the caveat that any works have to be non-penetrative (i.e. no people/objects are allowed to enter the body), cannot involve ageplay, consent play, or bodily fluids/waste, and MUST be filtered under suggestive themes. For those affected by moderator action following the previously made changes, you are free to reupload your characters so long as the works they are involved in keep in mind our guidelines. We apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused!

   Additionally, we have also added General Rule 11 to combat fetish mining. It reads as follows:


  • 11. Fetish mining, which involves soliciting fetish art without the knowledge and consent of the user involved, is a bannable offense.

User Questions

1. What is considered fetish art? How does staff determine what is/isn’t fetish?


  • Fetish art consists of content that is intended to provide sexual gratification to the viewer/artist via a specific scenario/object.  The artwork may or may not initially appear “SFW” to someone who is not aware of said fetish. Regardless, if any content is intended to satisfy a particular fetish, it MUST be filtered under suggestive themes.

2. Are drawings of trans characters or characters who do not conform to gender norms considered fetish art?


  • No. Trans characters and gender non-conforming characters are not inherently fetishistic and would never need a sexual themes filter on this basis alone.  We have been and always will be an LGBTQ+ positive and friendly space. We care deeply about making other LGBTQ+ folks comfortable in all of Art Fight's spaces and ask that if you see any homophobic, transphobic, or other forms of discriminatory content on-site to please report it or contact a moderator about it as soon as possible.

3. Are drawings of fat characters considered fetish art?


  • No. Drawings of fat characters on their own are not inherently fetishistic and will not be considered fetish art. The same goes for any body type, whether exaggerated cartoonishly or not. The initial wording of “over-exaggerated proportions” was intended to refer to fetish art, not cartoonish works or different body types. We recognize the initial wording was poor, and it has since been removed.

4. Will I get banned if I unintentionally create fetish art?


  • No. We only ban for fetish mining if we are sure, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that it is both intentional and targeting minors or non-consenting adults. Users who have unintentionally appealed to a fetish will not be punished. For fetish characters needing moderator action, such as those without a suggestive themes filter or characters participating in fetishes that are disallowed on Art Fight, you would simply be alerted to the changes made by a moderator after the necessary actions were taken.
  • If you have any specific questions about particular characters or fetishes, feel free to DM a moderator that is okay with receiving questions about suggestive content.
Other Updates


  • A minor update has been made to the phrasing regarding NSFW content involving feral characters. Previously, the text had stated: “This includes characters who are sapient, alien creatures/animals, or monsters/fictional creatures.” This text was intended to specify that ANY feral creature, regardless of being made-up or real, couldn’t be drawn in suggestive or explicit situations. Due to confusion regarding these rules, we have altered it to read: “This also includes fictional or made-up animals.”

Additionally, we’ve made some minor changes to the following rules:

  • General Rule 7: Specified that comments are included
  • Upload Rule 1: Added additional bullet point
  • Upload Rule 3: Added additional bullet point regarding uncredited photography
  • Upload Rule 5: Specified policy on smaller creators
  • Upload Rule 6: Clarified that characters based on current real life tragic events are not allowed
  • Spirit of Art Fight Rule 6: Clarified that "point farming" is not allowed
  • Filtering/Attack Guides: We're currently working on updating visuals and removing old/inaccurate images from our guides


   We acknowledge the unfortunate timing of this newpost. We’ve been actively working on these changes throughout the week, and believe it'd be ideal to sort everything out on-site before the stream so as to not confuse the influx of users that become active once the theme has been revealed. We understand the importance of this issue, and want as many people as possible to see the changes made, so we will be linking back to these updates in the next few newsposts to ensure that all users are well aware of the changes made.

Comments (280)

dipper said:
Way more understandable and agreeable. Thank you for making this change and listening to your community!
OwlDust said:
Thanks for the re-write and further clarification. Yes, it's near the event but that doesn't matter, y'all did something and fixed things that people were concerned about. I appreciate seeing mods actually fix things, as I'm on another site where the site owners basically mine for money and refuse to fix anything or address concerns, going so far to intentionally make events that are passive aggressive towards complaints. It's wonderful to see a site that the owners and mods actually discuss and work on the site because they care about it and the user base. Many applauds for your team, keep up the good work.
understandable.
Oh, thank god. The previous rule would have been so easy for someone to exploit, since literally every single thing that exists or doesn't exist is someone's fetish. Not to mention, rules banning all fetish content are most often used to get rid of queer (especially trans), fat and disabled people from spaces. I know that wasn't the intent here, because I've been on AF long enough to know this place is very queer-friendly at least, but such a ban opens the door incredibly wide for bad actors. Basically, thank god for this update
Thank god
Akivaq said:
btw if you hover over the question mark in the character filter checkbox, it still says "kink, fetish, or porn is not allowed", might wanna fix that to prevent confusion lol

ty for listening to us again, im so glad this has been cleared up
W update, thank you for the clarification and for taking user concerns into consideration with these changes!!  I'm especially grateful for the reassurance regarding GNC characters and various body types.
i am very happy abt this time to listen to Normal Battle - 2023 Redux from Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne: Lucifer's Call featuring Dante from the Devil May Cry series
i was a little concerned abt the fetish rule, thank y'all for clarifying and fixing things! 
You guys are so rad, thank you for this ❤️
Honestly, allowing fetish art again with more ‘restrictions’ is quite unsettling for me. I am unfamiliar with most types of fetishes, so I could potentially be a victim of fetish mining, and even though I have permissions that do not allow fetishes with my characters, I’m still very concerned that someone might try to do something because it’s ‘SFW’, especially because I’m still legally considered a minor, so I’m very unsure about how to feel about this change
W
thank you for listening to people’s concerns !!!
YIPPEE!!!
THANK YOU MODS